Principals shape whether teachers stay. The research points to a short list of things you control: a strong induction program with a same-subject mentor, protected time to plan with colleagues, and leadership teachers describe as supportive.
This playbook is for principals and assistant principals who want to keep the teachers they've hired. Each section ends with what to do this semester.
Turnover costs more than a vacancy
Every teacher who leaves takes training, relationships and knowledge of your students with them. The Learning Policy Institute estimated that each teacher who leaves "can cost as much as $20,000 in an urban district" (Carver-Thomas and Darling-Hammond, 2017 (opens in a new tab)).
The same report found about two-thirds of teachers who leave do so for reasons other than retirement, most often dissatisfaction with working conditions and administrative support. Those are the reasons you can affect.
Your leadership is the biggest lever
Several large studies link principals to retention:
- Supportive administration. Teachers who strongly disagree that their administration is supportive are "more than twice as likely to leave their school or teaching" as those who strongly agree (Learning Policy Institute).
- Leadership improvements. In New York City middle schools, "improvements in school leadership especially" were associated with reductions in teacher turnover (Kraft, Marinell and Yee, 2016).
- Keeping the best teachers. In Tennessee, more effective principals saw lower turnover, and that lower turnover was "concentrated among high-performing teachers" (Grissom and Bartanen, 2019 (opens in a new tab)).
More effective principals see lower turnover, concentrated among their highest-performing teachers.
This semester: Ask your teachers, in writing and anonymously, two questions: "What should I keep doing?" and "What one thing would make your job more manageable?" Report back what you'll change.
Build induction around a same-subject mentor
Induction works best as a package. A 2004 analysis of first-year teachers by Ingersoll and Smith estimated predicted first-year turnover by the support teachers received:
| Induction support in the first year | Predicted turnover after year one |
|---|---|
| None | 40% |
| Same-field mentor, common planning time and regular collaboration | 28% |
| Six induction supports | 24% |
A 2011 review of 15 studies found most showed positive effects of induction on retention, with one important caveat: a large randomized trial in urban, low-income schools found no effect on retention or classroom practice. Induction done as a checklist isn't enough. Mentors need time, training and a match by subject.
Federal data supports mentoring too. Among teachers who began in 2007-08, 86% of those assigned a first-year mentor were still teaching five years later, compared with 71% of those without one (NCES, 2015 (opens in a new tab)).
This semester: Confirm every first- and second-year teacher has a mentor in the same subject or grade, with a shared planning period or a standing weekly meeting on the calendar.
Protect time to plan together
Collaborative planning appears in nearly every retention finding above. Beginning teachers who planned and collaborated with other teachers were less likely to move or leave (Smith and Ingersoll, 2004).
Protecting that time is a scheduling decision. Build common planning periods into the master schedule by grade or subject, and keep them free of administrative announcements.
Hold stay interviews, not just exit interviews
Exit interviews tell you why someone left. Stay interviews ask the teachers you want to keep what would keep them. The Institute of Education Sciences describes them as "proactive, intentional conversations with teachers they want to retain to determine what it will take to keep them from leaving" (REL West, 2025 (opens in a new tab)). Utah districts interviewed more than 200 early-career teachers this way in 2023-24, according to WestEd.
The evidence for stay interviews comes mainly from nursing and business; there isn't yet a causal study in K-12 schools. Treat them as a way to hear problems early.
This semester: Hold a 20-minute stay interview with each teacher you most want to keep before winter break. Ask what they enjoy, what frustrates them, and what would make them consider leaving.
In Texas: use the new funding
House Bill 2 (2025) gives Texas principals new tools:
- Mentoring funds. The mentorship allotment pays $3,000 per beginning teacher, up to 40 per district, starting in 2026-27 (TEA, September 2025 (opens in a new tab)). Use it to pay and train mentors.
- Retention raises. The Teacher Retention Allotment raises pay for teachers with three or more years of experience: $4,000 or $8,000 in districts with 5,000 or fewer students, and $2,500 or $5,000 in larger districts (TEA, June 2025).
- Incentive pay for top teachers. Teacher Incentive Allotment designations range from $3,000 to $36,000 per designated teacher in 2026-27, with a new Acknowledged level districts can first submit in fall 2026 (TEA, September 2025).
Make sure your teachers know what they're eligible for. A raise nobody understands doesn't help retention.
Next step
Pick two actions for this semester: mentor matches for every new teacher, and stay interviews with your strongest teachers. Put both on your calendar today.




